Confusion about NEB calculation

Vasp transition state theory tools

Moderator: moderators

Post Reply
Posts: 1
Joined: Tue Aug 04, 2020 11:52 am

Confusion about NEB calculation

Post by nyShi »

Dear Professor,
I am a beginner of VASP software.Recently, when I was learning to calculate the energy barrier of the S atom crossing an edge of the Ni55 cluster, several problems appeared.I can’t figure out the reason by myself, So i hope to find suggestions and solutions here.
The problem is that in NEB calculation, the energy of IS and FS is too far from the energy of five images. This is unreasonable. I don’t know what went wrong.Based on the first question, I did a single-point energy test. The energy difference between TS and IS is 0.58 eV, which is reasonable, so I don’t know if which parameter is wrong in the NEB process.At the same time, I also did a frequency verification of the transition state (03), which showed that it was correct, so I was really at a loss as to the reason why the energy barrier was too large. All the data was packed in the attachment compression package.
Hope to get your attention and thank you in advance!
S Diffusion on Ni55
(4.02 MiB) Downloaded 205 times
Site Admin
Posts: 1976
Joined: Tue Apr 26, 2005 4:25 am

Re: Confusion about NEB calculation

Post by graeme »

Your calculation setting have to be the same for the endpoints and the NEB. In your case, it looks like the endpoints were spin polarized and the NEB was not. If you turn on spin polarization for your band, the energies should line up better.
Post Reply