Hello everyone!
I hope you are all doing well in these difficult times! I am trying to calculate the ZPE for the initial minimum of an elementary step. After the dymmatrix calculation, I get 23 imaginary frequencies of which most of them are near zero. I used the dymzpbar.pl script and it resulted in a zpe of 0.634 eV. The zpe of the saddle was 2.094 eV (with one img freq). This results in a very high zpe correction to the barrier of 1.46 eV which doesn't make sense. Can someone take a look at the files attached (including optimization of the initial) and let me know where I am going wrong? I highly appreciate your time on this! Thank you!
many imaginary freq for initial minimum
Moderator: moderators
many imaginary freq for initial minimum
 Attachments

 ini_freq.tar.gz
 (17.52 MiB) Downloaded 94 times
Re: many imaginary freq for initial minimum
Something is not right. I don't see any obvious problems in the INCAR, but the frequencies do not make sense. I'll look into it.
Please don't use this data in any subsequent calculation  you need 3 nearzero modes at a minimum for things to make sense.
Please don't use this data in any subsequent calculation  you need 3 nearzero modes at a minimum for things to make sense.
Re: many imaginary freq for initial minimum
Hello Graeme!
Hope you are doing well.
I resolved this problem by including more atoms (top two layers) from the slab in the calculation. Now I have no imaginary modes (as expected).
Thank you for your time on this!
Regards,
Keerthan.
Hope you are doing well.
I resolved this problem by including more atoms (top two layers) from the slab in the calculation. Now I have no imaginary modes (as expected).
Thank you for your time on this!
Regards,
Keerthan.
Re: many imaginary freq for initial minimum
fantastic!