Problem in interpolation with nebmake.pl script

Vasp transition state theory tools

Moderator: moderators

dwaipayan
Posts: 9
Joined: Wed Nov 20, 2019 7:21 am

Problem in interpolation with nebmake.pl script

Post by dwaipayan »

Dear Sir,

I have used nebmake.pl to create 1 image, but every time the image is created outside the zone of the initial and final state and sometimes the image structure is completely different. Here I attached the initial, image and the final states' POSCAR and POSCAR.xsf files. Please look at these. The discrepancies can be found in: Row Co-ordinate
1 x
4 x
5 x,z
6 x,y
7 z
Regards,
Dwaipayan Chakraborty
Attachments
POSCARs.rar
(4.37 KiB) Downloaded 274 times
graeme
Site Admin
Posts: 1948
Joined: Tue Apr 26, 2005 4:25 am
Contact:

Re: Problem in interpolation with nebmake.pl script

Post by graeme »

The problem is that the atoms are not in a consistent order in your initial and final structures. The nebmake.pl script will interpolate between the initial position of atom i to the final position of atom i. If you reorder the atoms in your final state structure so that they are as close to their position in the initial state, your interpolated band will be reasonable.
dwaipayan
Posts: 9
Joined: Wed Nov 20, 2019 7:21 am

Re: Problem in interpolation with nebmake.pl script

Post by dwaipayan »

Thank you, sir, for your reply.

I realized is that the initial and final ion positions differ very much and they are not in order. But I have one doubt if you please look at the .xsf files, there is only one atom 1 and the x coordinate of that in initial structure is 6.402489 , in final strucutre is 1.715433 but in the image that is 8.684338. How it can be?

Another thing is that in initial and final structure due to periodic boundary condition some coordinate changes form 14.50 to -0.022 (lattice parameter is 14.53), should I then write 0.022 as 14.51 and interpolate?

Can we only interpolate the position of the atom which is diffusing and let the other atom be at the position of the initial one and do the NEB calculation?
graeme
Site Admin
Posts: 1948
Joined: Tue Apr 26, 2005 4:25 am
Contact:

Re: Problem in interpolation with nebmake.pl script

Post by graeme »

The interpolation will deal with the periodic boundary conditions - don't worry about that. Just get the relative order of the atoms in the initial and final state correct.
dwaipayan
Posts: 9
Joined: Wed Nov 20, 2019 7:21 am

Re: Problem in interpolation with nebmake.pl script

Post by dwaipayan »

Sir,

1.I have ordered the atoms in the proper way and then used nebmake.pl. Now everything is coming nice expect the coordinate of the single atom which will diffuse (No 1 in the attached file).

2. Can we only interpolate the position of the atom which is diffusing and let the other atom be at the position of the initial one and do the NEB calculation?
Attachments
POSCAR_new_initial.txt
(1.54 KiB) Downloaded 270 times
POSCAR_new_image.txt
(1.54 KiB) Downloaded 268 times
POSCAR_new_final.txt
(1.54 KiB) Downloaded 280 times
graeme
Site Admin
Posts: 1948
Joined: Tue Apr 26, 2005 4:25 am
Contact:

Re: Problem in interpolation with nebmake.pl script

Post by graeme »

You typically want to find a minimum energy path between two stable structures. As atom 1 moves, the other atoms relax, and you typically want that.

If you want the other atoms frozen, then you can explicitly freeze them in your DFT calculation, calculate new initial and final states (with the same locations of the frozen atoms) and then setup an NEB calculation using those endpoint structures.
dwaipayan
Posts: 9
Joined: Wed Nov 20, 2019 7:21 am

Re: Problem in interpolation with nebmake.pl script

Post by dwaipayan »

Thank you very much sir for clearing my doubts.

But why the coordinates of the atom 1, which moves, are coming out the range (of the initial and the final structure) in the image structures?
graeme
Site Admin
Posts: 1948
Joined: Tue Apr 26, 2005 4:25 am
Contact:

Re: Problem in interpolation with nebmake.pl script

Post by graeme »

Oh, because the script finds the shortest path between the initial and final state (the minimum image convention). In your case, atom 1 goes across one side of the box to the other, as allowed by the periodic boundary conditions.
dwaipayan
Posts: 9
Joined: Wed Nov 20, 2019 7:21 am

Re: Problem in interpolation with nebmake.pl script

Post by dwaipayan »

Thank you very much sir for clearing my doubts.
dwaipayan
Posts: 9
Joined: Wed Nov 20, 2019 7:21 am

Re: Problem in interpolation with nebmake.pl script

Post by dwaipayan »

Dear Sir,

Just one query when looking at the OUTCAR files, should I look at the CHAIN+TOTAL forces to meet the convergence criteria (0.01eV/Angst in my case) or the individual CHAIN forces and TOTAL forces to meet the convergence criteria also?
graeme
Site Admin
Posts: 1948
Joined: Tue Apr 26, 2005 4:25 am
Contact:

Re: Problem in interpolation with nebmake.pl script

Post by graeme »

just the CHAIN+TOTAL
dwaipayan
Posts: 9
Joined: Wed Nov 20, 2019 7:21 am

Re: Problem in interpolation with nebmake.pl script

Post by dwaipayan »

Thank you very much, sir.
dwaipayan
Posts: 9
Joined: Wed Nov 20, 2019 7:21 am

Re: Problem in interpolation with nebmake.pl script

Post by dwaipayan »

Dear Sir,

In case of NEB calculation (as implemented in VASP) the OUTCAR prints the CHAIN+TOTAL forces which have to be looked to check the convergence criteria (0.01eV/Angst in my case) has been met or not (as you said) but for the CI-NEB calculation there is no CHAIN+TOTAL forces printed in the OUTCAR file. So in this case of the CI-NEB how can I check the force convergence from the OUTCAR file?
graeme
Site Admin
Posts: 1948
Joined: Tue Apr 26, 2005 4:25 am
Contact:

Re: Problem in interpolation with nebmake.pl script

Post by graeme »

If you look in the OUTCAR, after the lines:

POSITION TOTAL-FORCE (eV/Angst)
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

you can see the NEB forces (total+chain). Then you can also see the forces used for the convergence criterion, as in:

FORCES: max atom, RMS 0.523540 0.175844
FORCE total and by dimension 1.098148 0.452968
dwaipayan
Posts: 9
Joined: Wed Nov 20, 2019 7:21 am

Re: Problem in interpolation with nebmake.pl script

Post by dwaipayan »

Dear Sir,

I am getting the following:



NEB: Tangent
----------------------------------------------
0.28401 0.15083 -0.85009
-0.03674 0.01548 0.02125
-0.06085 0.03615 -0.02879
-0.02719 -0.02189 -0.02387
-0.02327 -0.01379 -0.02847
-0.09571 0.01797 -0.05116
-0.09799 0.03135 0.09570
0.01741 -0.03167 -0.03956
0.00893 -0.04090 -0.00792
-0.07237 0.10393 -0.03189
-0.04245 0.01496 0.01044
-0.00678 -0.01145 -0.02421
0.00028 0.00077 -0.01945
0.00428 0.00953 -0.02647
-0.02276 -0.00299 0.03473
0.00709 -0.04561 -0.01974
-0.00032 -0.07873 -0.02466
-0.04048 0.00042 -0.00358
-0.03768 0.05185 -0.02282
-0.00355 -0.00527 -0.02270
-0.00790 -0.00809 -0.02624
-0.03419 0.00884 0.01578
0.03700 -0.03243 -0.03092
0.03967 -0.12201 -0.01597
0.00800 -0.05779 0.00950
-0.06591 -0.01358 -0.00341
-0.02356 0.06783 -0.01507
-0.02208 0.00062 -0.01807
-0.02026 -0.00508 -0.03044
-0.02241 0.01079 0.02079
-0.01056 -0.01736 -0.01355
0.00489 -0.07341 -0.02422
0.00588 -0.03814 -0.02594
-0.06188 0.06021 -0.01623
-0.04356 0.00101 -0.00717
-0.01480 -0.03052 -0.02617
-0.02866 -0.05164 -0.03092
0.08760 0.02372 -0.03037
-0.06804 -0.00830 0.00004
-0.00144 -0.01833 0.01245
0.02359 -0.08945 -0.02225

NEB: forces: par spring, perp REAL, dneb 0.009885 0.017753 0.000000
NEB: distance to prev, next image, angle between 0.725551 0.727528 149.562590
NEB: projections on to tangent (spring, REAL) 0.009885 -0.075397

stress matrix after NEB project (eV)
-0.79328 -0.55740 0.30884
-0.55740 1.75197 -0.15657
0.30884 -0.15657 -0.11039
FORCES: max atom, RMS 0.007795 0.003173
FORCE total and by dimension 0.020319 0.007514
Stress total and by dimension 2.138233 1.751966



The EDIFFG in INCAR is -0.01. Does that means the each component of the forces written under the NEB tangent line should be less than -0.01 or I have to just check the RMS value written at last?

Is this calculation converged?
Post Reply